She Must Have Provoked Him


Sitting at a party with friends and family, someone mentioned an acquaintance whose husband and mother-in-law had beaten her mercilessly earlier that day, in front of her twelve year old daughter. If the details were not horrific enough, what appalled me further, was the barrage of comments that followed. I am still reeling in the aftermath of the revelation.

Male 1 : I have heard this has happened before, but I know the husband’s family. I do not think they are capable of doing this.

Female 1 : She must have said or done something nasty, I am sure.

Female 2 : Women should realise that men are aggressive and know when to back off or otherwise face the consequences.

Me: Isn’t this his second marriage? Didn’t his first wife leave for similar reasons?

Male 2 : That may be the case but she got married knowing his past, whether it is true or not. Why would she marry him if she knew he was a wife beater?

Male 3 : Even if he has temper issues, forewarned is forearmed. Why create situations that lead to this sort of outcome?

Female 3 : I agree. She must have done something to provoke him. Think about it. It seems she had a black eye, bruises all over her face and body. Her mother-in-law’s nails left scratch marks on her neck. I am sure she must have hit back too. I mean, I am quite sure she would have.

Female 1 : She called me to ask if her daughter and she could stay over till she figured out what to do. She was crying and I felt bad but I cannot get involved in someone’s personal life. They have to sort out their own matters.

Female 2: That was wise of you. I believe this has happened a few times before. Since she has no surviving close family, she would keep turning up at your doorstep at every little tiff in their house.

Male 2 : In all honesty, he has money and decent looks. We were all wondering what he saw in her. She has to adjust. That shit happens in marriages. She should put it behind her for the sake of the child. Where will she go? If she goes to the cops, she has ruined her future and that of her daughter, along with the family reputation. We are not out to raise our hands on women unless the woman really pushes the wrong buttons.

Female Chorus and Male Chorus : I agree. She must have done something to provoke him.

I listened, flabbergasted. I protested vehemently and was brushed off. I sat at a dinner table with friends and family, who I thought I knew. I realised, after all these years, that I knew nothing about them. Nothing at all. This was a lost battle and I laid down my arms temporarily, but my words are my sword and I will have my say, one way or another. I will speak up for all those women who do not have a voice because it is muffled under violence and then smothered further by the insensitivity of society.

So she provoked him. So what? She disagreed with him? Nagged him? Criticised him? Whatever she did, can it condone raising a hand brutally and collectively on her? Vocalise your rage if needed. Would these standards apply to your own daughters, sisters or mothers? Will you continue to wear the sanctimonious rose – tinted glasses if it is your daughter who underwent this aggression and will you pardon the man who beats her to a pulp? If she was bludgeoned to death in a fit of rage, is that the outcome you seek, to condemn this kind of atrocity? Who are you, me or anyone to be a moral barometer in someone’s bedroom? Who are we, to be judge and jury and apply our standards of justice on another? Violence is unacceptable. Period.

Under provocation, animals are supposed to lash out, not human beings. We were placed on the top of the hierarchy because we were gifted with rationale, emotion and intellect. Yet, we sink so rapidly into base behaviour. Yes, we get angry. No, we do not have the license to give that anger, free rein and unleash it on another person. Yes, we are emotional. No, we cannot cast aside emotion and be so desensitised that we find excuses for the cruel acts of others. Let us not remain panelists on a talk show but become activists on the stage of justice.

I am a humanist, first and a feminist, second. Yes, she provoked me. She provoked me enough to stand up for her. Through intervention or interaction, I stand by her and every woman or man who is at the receiving end of violence. To all of you, I want to say…

‘Do not get buried under the weight of your gaping wounds. Reach out. You are not alone. There are many of us, beyond the confines of limited thinking, who will shield you, till you bloom into the beautiful person you were born to be.’


Alisha “Priti” Kirpalani is the author of “A Smattering Of Darkness: Short and Shorter Twisted Tales,” (available on Kindle Unlimited) a collection of short stories of varying lengths encapsulating the grey shades of the human psyche. Her new novel will be released later this year.

If you enjoyed reading this post, please recommend it ❤ and share. Find me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s